on this site
Vol 1 Issue 2 2010
Vincent T Francisco, PhD
Rites of Passage as a Framework for Community Interventions with Youth
This article discusses the potential value of adopting a rites of passage framework for developing community interventions for youth and suggests principles for its application. We propose a contemporary working definition of the concept, how it could reshape the way we approach community and youth development, and 20 core components of a rites of passage process developed from our work experience spanning over 40 years.
Please see the PDF version for the complete article, including tables and figures.
Our definition of rites of passage as well as our specification of the structural elements that compose them comes from the lead author's experience spanning over 40 years of practice in creating effective rites of passage experiences that are grounded in the community. These experiences led to the creation of The Center for the Advancement of Youth, Family & Community Services, Inc. in 1990, a non-profit institute focused on “promoting positive youth development and [to] assist[ing] children in the transition through adolescence to becoming healthy adults connected to their communities. We accomplish this by creating effective school and community-based strategies in partnership with parents, teachers, counselors, and community leaders” (ROPE, n.d.).
The Center has created ROPE© a multi-year intervention with communities that has been used throughout the US, Canada and Europe with an estimated 100,000 youth over the past 30 years. For more information on The Center, ROPE©, and other related experiences, please visit www.rope.org.
What do we mean by a rite of passage?
What happens without meaningful rites of passage?
So what is a real rite of passage?
During this time of transition there will be a great deal of uncertainty and mystery that causes much anxiety. It is a place of liminality where social status becomes lost or unclear while the initiate undergoes precise training in values and ethics that inform and guide behavior. There are periods of extreme stress or “ordeals” that help to compel the child to experience the full range of human emotions and potential.
Almost all the examples of rites of passage from the anthropology literature are highly prescriptive. They were intended to initiate youth in small, highly homogeneous communities, where consensus about community values and appropriate behaviors can be easily established, into a rather limited number of adult roles. It should be noted that certain culturally defined rites of passage for youth still exist in western culture. Such events as Bar and Bat Mitzvahs for observant Jews and La Quinceanera for Latinos are practiced by a small percentage of the population. The significance of such events for development has been noted (see Schoenfeld 1994; Stewart, 2005). But these are the exceptions. Indeed, in today’s pluralistic societies where there are multiple possibilities for values and ethics that inform and guide expectations for behavior, one could reasonably ask: can meaningful rites of passage be developed? We believe they can. The challenge for community psychologists is to help the communities articulate their shared values and develop processes and rituals that effectively impart these values to youth.
The next section of this paper lays out some of the key structural elements, derived from over 40 years of practice, which can create effective rites of passage experiences that are grounded in the community.
Characteristics of rites of passage
The recognition that adolescent development and community development are intimately tied means that the community must meet to agree upon values and ethics (#2) they want to convey to their children. The hallmark of a community-based rite of passage strategy is the creation of intentional, inclusive community dialogues to address these important questions. We have used techniques such as World Café (Brown & Isaacs, 2005) and Appreciative Inquiry (Whitney & Trosten-Bloom, 2003) to facilitate such dialogues among a diversity of youth and adult citizens. Our experience suggests that the Golden Rule (“Do unto others, as you would have others do unto you”) and its variants across all cultures and religions, is a good place to start. There also seems to be a consensus across communities that children and youth are expected to become good students, achieve academically, and have good physical and mental health. Clarification of values must precede the creation of experiences that foster youths’ understanding, appreciation and commitment to these expectations.
The third element–Program success relies on relationships—relates to issues of program replication and innovation transfer (Smale, 1993; Martinez-Brawley, 1995). We believe that the success of all youth development designs ultimately hinge dependent upon the relationships between youth and adults, and between the adults and the “program.” Consequently, social science and educational programs cannot be simply transferred, intact, from one community to another. Successful innovation transfer only occurs when people within a setting are intimately connected to the creation and/or adaptation of a strategy. Implications for practice: First, significant preparatory time must be spent in building relationships and capacity among the participants; and second, contemporary rites of passage will appear different depending upon the culture and context of the community. Therefore, they typically lie outside the “evidence-based” program paradigm which calls for a prescriptive set of activities rather than a prescriptive set of guiding principles that inform community and youth development practice. This does not mean that the effectiveness of a particular rites of passage experience developed by a community cannot be examined, but rather, that those set of experiences may only have validity in that community, and cannot be simply transferred to another context with the expectation of similar outcomes.
If relationships are key, then those who are to be the Initiators of youth’s coming of age (Elders) need training and professional development to build their personal awareness and resources, i.e., you can only bring someone as far as you have been yourself (#4). Elders must come to peace with their own lives in regard to aspirations achieved and those unattained in order to move on to a place of generativity (Erikson, 1968). Individuals need to undergo their own initiatory experience and rite of passage to aid his or her transition to maturity and able to become an Elder and initiator of youth.
Implication for practice: staff training is critical!
Coming of age in a rites of passage orientation to youth and community development involves creating and supporting intentional environments that transmit essential values and ethics that guide and inform expectations for socially appropriate behaviors (#6).
The seventh element–rituals—often has emotionally charged connotations; for many, it is usually associated with ceremony and sacred and religious acts. But the term also refers to a detailed sequence of actions that are regularly followed. Indeed, many aspects of school life and secular society are highly ritualized (McLaren, 1997), e.g., the regularity of change of class bells or tones, the systematic organization of classroom seating, and the routinization of the school day represents a ritual that almost all students experience, a ritual that may have unintended consequences on mediating their attention.
Rituals can play a part in social and emotional learning (McClaren, 1997) and can set a tone and impact climate in ways that help to create a productive context for learning (Sarason, 2004). In rites of passage, the “program” or design elements carefully consider the small details of setting and how the participants begin each activity, separate and change from the previous activity, and how they end their time together in more intentional ways that can affect behavior with more potency. Sarason (1972) describes at length the importance and necessary ingredients in the creation of settings as a central consideration in a community psychology.
The creation of challenging emotional experiences—adversity (8)—deepens life’s lessons and sears them into our lives forever. Our new paradigm challenges us to provide “teachable moments” capable of searing into the emerging adult’s mind essential information related to values and ethics that inform and guide expectations for behavior.
The essence of resiliency is the body and spirit’s capability of resuming its shape or position after being subjected to stress and capable of rapid recovery from an emotional shock (Werner & Smith, 1982; Benard, 2004). One powerful way to gain a solid identity is to engage in structured ordeals and challenges that test one’s self and from which one can emerge with a greater sense of meaning and purpose. For example, we often give students basic training in orienteering skills and then they must find their way out of the woods without adult assistance.
Children and youth grow up in a cacophony of sound (music, computer games) and mediated togetherness (cell phones, Facebook, etc.) that makes the “call to adventure,” the internal alarm clock awakening them to the coming of age process, almost inaudible. Creating opportunities for silence and to spend time alone—the ninth and tenth elements—help a young person develop an internal dialogue for narrating and making sense of what is going on around them. It affords them a place to contemplate and consider the great complexities of the world and how they fit within it.
In each era, there have been stories, myths or legends (#11) that help to lead civilizations and cultures through the mysteries of the universe and to guide daily living practices. Today’s stories are largely superficial and portray realities that equate life satisfaction with consumption. This drives contemporary culture, especially adolescents, to look for spiritual salvation at the shopping mall.
As Wynee, (1987, p. 482) notes, “If we want to change our lives, we must first change our stories.” At the community level, the story of rites of passage as a framework to inform and guide a new paradigm for youth and community development is rich and steeped in history. It can serve to tie many of the existing theories of youth development together in ways that really speak to both the conscious and unconscious needs of adolescents. When the community creates and enacts a rite of passage story for their children, they are really creating a way to remember what the important ingredients are for a healthy psychological sense of community essential for positive youth development.
Knowing who we are at a deep and meaningful level cannot happen unless we come to know ourselves within the context of nature and the environment (#12). Recent research, e.g., LaChance (2006); Louv (2005), suggests that separation from nature has negative consequences for child and human development. Integrated into a meaningful rites of passage experience are opportunities that intentionally reconnect children to the natural environment. Implication for practice: intentional activities in the natural world are critical for youth to feel a sense of place.
If you don’t know where you are and have no connection with where you have come from how could you know where to go in the future? These questions challenge our youth development work to help connect them to their ancestral roots (#13). What is the culture and religion of “their people” and what does this mean regarding values and ethics? Every community has religious and civic organizations that hold the history of their children’s ancestors. Cultural identity development is one of the essential building blocks and protective factors of youth development (Hill, 2002), especially for youth of color.
Contemporary application of this element calls for engaging diverse religious and cultural constituencies and institutions within a community. Secular rites of passage do not usurp religious or cultural rites; they affirm their importance and help to forge links with our common humanity.
Contemporary rites of passage engage youth in ways that unveil the potency and importance of play, the fourteenth element. It establishes systematic ways for children to explore and experiment with activities that give them joy and invite transcendence. If you help a child find their “bliss” – something they can immerse themselves in with great passion, from which they receive unbridled joy, you have given them the best “protective factor” (Hawkins, Catalano & Miller, 1992) against mental and physical health problems – for the rest of their life (Blumenkrantz, 2000).
Letting go of something important, whether it is in the symbolic act of giving away (#15) “childish behaviors and attitudes” or some material possession, conveys a reality that change – leaving something dear in the past behind – is an integral part of the shift in consciousness that accompanies a healthy coming of age process. Moving to a rites of passage paradigm also involves a “give away” for some members of the community. Embracing such an initiatory process may mean giving up the simplistic bromides of educational policy and youth development that routinely come into fashion, e.g., “No Child Left Behind” (testing is the answer), “Just Say No,” “Zero Tolerance.”
Awakening to Spirit and Non-ordinary reality (#16) is a challenging construct to grapple with in a society and culture that has strict codes of conduct about chemically induced changes in the perception of reality. There are age limits for the use of reality altering beverages (alcohol), and drugs whose primary purpose is to alter consciousness (e.g., marijuana, LSD, Ecstasy) are illegal. Yet, such substances are highly sought after by teenagers who are innately compelled to experiment with non-ordinary states of reality on their pathway to adulthood (Weil & Rosen, 1983). No matter how misguided and health compromising their efforts to seek non-ordinary states of reality, teenagers engage in risk taking behavior more than any other age group, (Lewis & Lewis, 1984). This desire points to their need for heightened experience, which for them helps to create meaning in their life.
We can either choose to support youth’s innate desire to unveil the mysteries of life through non-ordinary states of reality in health promoting ways, such as, vision quest (Foster 1980), meditation, yoga and relaxation (Rimer, 2007) movement and dance (Michael, 2003), playing in the zone with sports and hobbies (Cooper, 1998; Jackson & Delehanty, 1995) play as promoting transcendence and secular spirituality (Blumenkrantz 2000; Donaldson, 1993) or continue to suffer the consequences.
The way we provide opportunities for youth to engage in meaningful roles and bond to their family, schools and community is critical to a contemporary rite of passage. When children are given the skills and opportunities for meaningful involvement with their peers, family, school and community, and reinforced for their pro-social involvement, they are more likely to grow up well (Hawkins & Weiss, 1985). An obligation to service to the larger community (#17) is one way to help young people find meaning and purpose, while contributing to their sense of identity, as a valued and important member of their expanding world.
One way we integrate service into our work is by training high school students to become guides for the community rite of passage process. High School students can conduct lessons and serve as mentors for children entering the initiatory process in the 6th grade. Through the initiatory process, adolescents are oriented to recognize that service is an essential part of becoming a fully functioning adult in society. Such experiences come to be seen not as work -but as a committed act of conscience and belief in service as an expectation for living.
Growing up is a natural process accompanied by changes in the body. This physical change is often accompanied by intentional alterations of appearance (#18) to signal this change, e.g., tattoos, piercings and dressing in dramatic ways (Murdock, 1983). In traditional cultures and even western culture changes in body and dress through tattoos, piercing and altering clothing is the enactment of this element in a coming of age process. In a contemporary community-based rite of passage, the change of appearance may not be as dramatic as traditional cultures. External symbols might be as subtle as wearing special cloths or adornments that are awarded during public rites of passage. A high school mentor in a community-based rite of passage may wear a special identification badge or special uniform like if they are crossing guards or engaged in any other special function.
As a distinct stage of life, adolescence is a relatively recent “invention” in Western culture (Kett, 1977). In a sense it is a form of suspended animation since the physical process of coming of age - puberty - lasts about 12 to 18 months, but we essentially ask functional adults, i.e., capable at ages 11-13 of procreation, to “wait” to grow up for another 10 to 15 years. During this ‘waiting period” society must provide a clear gradient of opportunities for youth to demonstrate their new competencies and status (#19) on their way to adulthood. In contemporary rites of passage, youth engage in a process where they can see opportunities for ascending to increased status through meaningful roles. Chief among these opportunities is to become responsible for the initiation – rite of passage – of younger students. This can begin by conveying the importance of becoming a good student, achieving academically and engaging with healthy ways to play and recreate. High school students can mentor middle school students, helping them increase their commitment to academic achievement and convey the expectation that they will engage in finding healthy positive leisure time activities. Middle school students can then, in turn, support elementary school students to acquire the essential values, ethics and attitudes to inform and guide their development and attachment and bonding to school and the community.
Following different phases of contemporary rites of passage youth must be publicly recognized and affirmed via celebratory events (#20) for the advances they make towards coming of age. The events are marked by the initiates telling their story about lessons learned, and how they would use these lessons within their family, school and community to grow up well and become a contributing adult. Certificates of accomplishment, T-shirts, pins and other displays of recognition are provided that align themselves with the cultural context of the community, and provide for an external “change of appearance.”
The goal of this article has been to advocate the value of rites of passage as a conceptual framework for positive youth and community development. Indeed, we believe that such a framework represents a valuable paradigm shift and supports the adage that “it takes a whole child to raise a village.”
Arnett, J. J. (2000). Emerging adulthood: A theory of development from the late teens through the twenties. American Psychologist, 55(5), 469-480.
Arnett, J. J. (2004). Emerging adulthood: The winding road from the late teens through the twenties. New York: Oxford University Press.
Benard, B. (2004). Resiliency: What we have learned. San Francisco: WestEd.
Blos, P. (1979). The adolescent passage: Developmental issues. NY: International Universities Press.
Blumenkrantz, D. G. (1994). The rite way: Guiding youth to adulthood and the problem of communitas. Dissertation Abstract International, 57(11), 4645A. (UMI No. AAT 9713085).
Blumenkrantz, D. G. (2000). Let’s play: Initiating youth into the healthy world of play. In: T. Gullotta (Ed), Developing competent youth and strong communities through after school programming. Washington, DC: Child Welfare League of America Press.
Brown, J. with Isaacs, D and the World Café Community (2005). The World Café: Shaping our futures through conversations that matter. San Francisco: Berrett-Koehler.
(CASA) Commission on Substance Abuse at Colleges and Universities, (1994).Rethinking rites of passage: Substance abuse on America’s campuses. New York: National Center on Addiction and Substance Abuse at ColumbiaUniversity.
Donaldson, O. F. (1993). Playing by heart: The vision and practice of belonging. Deerfield Beach, FL: Health Communications.
Elkind, D. (1984). All grown up and no place to go. NY: Addison-Wesley.
Eller, C. A. (1991). Building a sense of community. In Todd, C.M. (Ed.), School-age connections. Urbana-Champaign, IL: University of Illinois Cooperative Extension Service.
Foster, S. (1988). The book of the vision quest: Personal transformation in the wilderness. New York: Prentice Hall Press.
Gillespie, J. (2009, February 17). Tattoos: A rite of Passage. The Queensland Times. Retrieved from http://www.qt.com.au/story/2009/02/17/tattoo-marks-rite-of-passage
Hawkins, J. D., Catalano, R. F., & Miller, J. Y. (1992). Risk and protective factors for alcohol and other drug problems in adolescence and early adulthood: Implications for substance abuse prevention. Psychological Bulletin, 112, 64-105.
Hawkins, J. D., & Weis, J. G. (1985). The social development model: An integrated approach to delinquency prevention. Journal of Primary Prevention, 6, 73-97.
Hill, P. (2002). Africentric rites of passage: Nurturing the next generation. In J. Lipford and C. Bradley (Eds.). Counseling African American families (pp. 61-71). Alexandria, VA: American Counseling Association.
Jackson, P., & Delehanty, H. (1995). Sacred hoops: Spiritual lessons of a hardwood warrior. New York, N.Y.: Hyperion Publisher.
Kett, J. F. (1977). Rites of passage: Adolescence in America, 1790 to the present. New York: Basic Books.
LaChance, A. (2006). The architecture of the soul: A unitive model of the human person. Berkeley, CA: North Atlantic Books.
Lewis, C. E., &, Lewis, M. A. (1984). Peer pressure and risk-taking behaviors in children. American Journal of Public Health, 74, 580-584.
Louv, R. (2005). Last Child in the Woods: Saving our children from nature deficit disorder. Chapel Hill, NC: Algonquin Books.
Martinez-Brawley, E. E. (1995). Knowledge diffusion and transfer of technology: Conceptual premises and concrete steps for human services innovators. Social Work, 40, 670-682.
McLaren, P. (1997). Schooling as a ritual performance: Toward a political economy of educational symbols and gestures. Boulder, CO: Rowman & Littlefield.
Michael, M. (2003). Surfing the creative edge with youth. Wild Heart Journal, 6(2).
Rimer, S. (2007, October 29). Less homework, more yoga, from a principal who hates stress. The New York Times, pp. A16.
ROPE (Rites of Passage Experience) n.d. Mission statement. Retrieved July 12, 2010 from www.rope.org/center.asp
Sarason, S. (1972). The creation of settings and the future societies. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Sarason, S. (1974). The psychological sense of community: Prospects for a community psychology. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Sarason, S. (2004). And what do you mean by learning? Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.
Schoenfeld, S. (1995). Recent publications on bar/bat mitzvah: Their implications for Jewish education research and their implications for Jewish education research and service. Religious Education, 89(4), 594-604.
Scott, D. G. (1998). Rites of passage in adolescent development: A reappraisal. Child & Youth Care Forum, 27(5), 317-335.
Smale, G. (1993). The nature of innovation and community-based practice. In E. E. Martinez-Brawley, & S. M. Delevan (Eds.), Transferring technology in the personal social services (pp. 6 -12). Washington, DC: NASW Press.
Stevenson, H. C. (1998). Raising Safe Villages: Cultural-ecological factors that influence the emotional adjustment of adolescents. Journal of Black Psychology, 24(1), 44-59.
Stewart, H. M. (2005). Senoritas and princesses: The quinceanara as a context for female development. Dissertation Abstracts International, 65 (7), 2770B. (UMI No. 319800)
Van Gennep, A. (1960). The rites of passage. (Monika B. Vizedom & Gabrielle L. Caffee, Trans.). Chicago: University of Chicago Press. (Original work published in 1909)
Weil, A., & Rosen W. (1983). From chocolate to morphine: Everything you need to know about mind-altering drugs. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt.
Werner, E. E., & Smith, R. S. (1982). Vulnerable, but invincible: A longitudinal study of resilient children and youth. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Whitney, D. & Trosten-Bloom, A. (2003). The power of appreciative inquiry: A practice guide to positive change. San Francisco: Berrett-Koehler.
Wynne, E. (1987). Storytelling. In L., C., Mahdi, S. Foster, and M. Little, (Eds.), Betwixt & between: Patterns of masculine and feminine initiation (pp. 482-488). La Salle, IL: Open Court.
David G. Blumenkrantz, PhD, & Marc B. Goldstein, PhD
Dr. David G. Blumenkrantz is the Executive Director of The Center for the Advancement of Youth, Family & Community Services in Glastonbury, CT, USA (Thecenter@rope.org).
Dr. Marc B. Goldstein is a professor of Psychology at Central Connecticut State University, New Britain, CT, USA (Goldsteinm@ccsu.edu).